A Socratic line-side tutor grounded only on Marlowe & Finch's own recipes and SFA food-safety rules. It coaches the foundational questions so the chefs' hours go to the line — and it refuses to improvise a shortcut or a recipe. A culinary-academy pedagogy concept · supports Eleanor, Marcus & Lily — never replaces them
The tree-nut is in the dish, not a garnish: fermented bunya nut is plated under the trout, and it also carries fish and dairy. How to take, flag and refuse the order safely.
Critical · allergen safetyMade to order, roughly 15 minutes from the call. When to fire it against the rest of the table so it lands at the pass risen, not collapsed. Lily owns the bake.
Intermediate · pastry timingThe beef-cheek & bone-marrow pithivier, pea velouté, build order and pour. Carries gluten and dairy — the allergen call still applies.
Foundational · platingCoffin Bay oysters — cold-chain, shucking, the SFA rules on live shellfish, and the shellfish allergen call at the table.
Critical · food safetyPouring the Meursault against the Adelaide Hills chardonnay for the barramundi — talking a guest through a pairing without overclaiming.
Foundational · serviceA guest declares a tree-nut allergy and asks for the ocean trout. What do you do?
B is right. The bunya nut is a fermented, structural component plated under the trout, so the tree-nut can't be "left off" — there's no version of this plate that's nut-free. The safe answer is to decline the dish for that guest, say plainly why, and steer them to a dish with no tree-nut declared (the pie floater carries gluten and dairy but no nut; the duck breast is dairy-only). Any allergy order is confirmed with the chef on the pass before it leaves.
A is the trap — see the next panel. C improvises a recipe, which the tutor will never do. D treats a declared allergy as negotiable, which it isn't.
Grounding: ocean trout allergens fish · tree-nut · dairy; pie floater gluten · dairy; duck breast dairy. SFA: a declared allergen is handled as anaphylaxis-risk regardless of stated severity."The trout is fine for a nut-allergy guest if we just leave off the praline — that takes the nut out."
No — don't serve this dish to a tree-nut-allergy guest. The nut isn't a garnish you can lift off. The recipe builds fermented bunya nut in under the trout as a core component — bunya nut is a tree-nut. Removing a praline doesn't remove the bunya nut, and trace contact is enough to trigger anaphylaxis. There is no nut-free version of this plate.
What you do instead: decline the trout for that guest, tell them plainly the dish contains tree-nut and can't be modified, and offer a dish with no tree-nut declared — the pie floater (gluten, dairy) or the duck breast (dairy). Confirm the allergy order with the chef on the pass before it leaves.
I won't suggest a substitute ingredient to "make it nut-free" — that's inventing a recipe, and an allergen call is not the place to improvise. If you think the card is wrong, that's a question for Lily or Marcus, not a workaround on the line.
Grounding: Smoked Tasmanian ocean trout, fermented bunya nut, dill — allergens fish · tree-nut · dairy; bunya nut is a structural, fermented element. SFA allergen-management guidance: a declared allergen cannot be served by removal of a visible component. Logged as a knowledge gap for chef review.Where the tutor stops: it coaches and flags, but it does not certify. Serious assessment and WSQ competency sign-off stay with Eleanor Marlowe and Marcus Tan; pastry timing sits with Lily Park. The tutor supports the trainers — it never replaces a chef's judgement on safety or a chef's signature on competency.
This page is a design concept, not a live system — the lessons, scores and the caught answer are hardcoded to show the interaction. The intended build is retrieval-augmented generation over M&F's own recipe and technique corpus, with a Socratic prompt that withholds the answer and questions back, plus a simple competency log. The honest point of difference is the safety floor: on an allergen or food-safety question the tutor cites the recipe and the SFA rule and refuses to improvise — it would sooner say "ask the chef" than invent a shortcut.